Terminated vs. Unterminated Coaxial Switches
Filed under Switches
In high-frequency RF and microwave routing, selecting the correct port configuration for inactive channels is critical to maintaining signal integrity. Electromechanical single pole double throw (SPDT) coaxial switches are broadly categorized into terminated and unterminated designs. Choosing between them requires a clear understanding of impedance matching, voltage standing wave ratio (VSWR), isolation, and power handling limitations. This guide contrasts these two switch topologies to help technical buyers and RF engineers specify the correct hardware for test and measurement setups.
- Standard Impedance
- 50 Ω
- Typical Termination Power Limit
- 1 W CW
- Terminated Switch Example
- Keysight N1810TL
- Unterminated Switch Example
- Keysight N1810UL
The Fundamental Structural Difference
The primary distinction between terminated and unterminated coaxial switches lies in how the switch treats the inactive or unused RF port.
In an unterminated switch, such as the Keysight N1810UL or the Keysight 8765B, the inactive channel is left open-circuited. The path is simply disconnected, leaving the center conductor suspended within the connector cavity.
In a terminated switch, such as the Keysight N1810TL or the Keysight 8762A, the internal mechanical actuator automatically connects the center conductor of the unused port to a built-in 50 Ω resistive load. This ensures that the unused port maintains its characteristic impedance even when it is not actively routing signals.
VSWR and Signal Reflections
When an active RF signal travels down a transmission line and encounters an unterminated (open-circuit) port, it experiences a massive impedance mismatch. Because there is no load to absorb the energy, the RF signal is reflected entirely back toward the source. This generates high voltage standing wave ratios (VSWR) on the transmission line.
These signal reflections can lead to voltage constructive interference, creating standing waves that risk damaging sensitive transmitters or source instrumentation. Conversely, terminated switches keep the inactive line matched. For example, the Keysight 8762A maintains a Voltage Standing Wave Ratio (SWR) of less than 1.1 from DC to 2 GHz and less than 1.2 from 2 to 4 GHz on its terminated paths, absorbing the unused energy and eliminating reflections.
Isolation and Signal Leakage
Unterminated ports can act as antennas, radiating RF energy into the switch cavity and causing signal leakage into neighboring channels. Terminating the unused port significantly improves channel-to-channel isolation.
In systems where isolation must remain high across a broad frequency spectrum, terminated configurations are often preferred to prevent crosstalk. With unterminated switches, isolation naturally degrades as frequencies increase. For example, the unterminated Keysight 8765B provides 90 dB of isolation from DC to 4 GHz, but this value falls to 60 dB at 18 to 20 GHz.
Power Handling and Thermal Constraints
While terminated switches offer excellent RF performance, they introduce physical power limits. The internal 50 Ω resistors are small and have limited heat dissipation capabilities.
For instance, the Keysight 8762A can handle up to 24 W of average RF power through its active, non-terminated transmission path. However, its internal 50 Ω termination has an average power rating of only 1 W (with a peak power rating of 100 W for a 10 µs pulse width at a 1% duty cycle). Similarly, the Keysight N1810TL has a maximum continuous RF power rating of 1 W CW for its internal termination. Exceeding these thermal limits will permanently damage the termination resistor, destroying the switch's impedance-matching properties.
Example instruments
Frequently asked questions
- When should an unterminated coaxial switch be used instead of a terminated one?
- An unterminated switch, such as the Keysight N1810UL or Keysight 8765B, is suitable when the signal sources connected to the inactive ports are shut off during switching, when high-power signals that would exceed a 1 W internal termination are present, or when external terminations are already integrated elsewhere in the system.
- What happens if the power rating of an internal termination is exceeded?
- If more than the rated power (such as 1 W CW for the Keysight N1810TL or Keysight 8762A) is applied to an internally terminated port, the internal resistor will overheat and fail. Once the resistor is damaged, the port will behave as an unterminated or highly mismatched load, resulting in severe reflections and a high VSWR.